5 Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers: Expert-Tested for Quality Brew

Searching for the best 5 cup coffee maker can feel like a quest for something that shouldn’t be so rare: a quality machine that makes just enough coffee for one or two people without hogging precious counter space. You want a great-tasting brew to start your day, but most options on the market are either oversized 12-cup behemoths or flimsy, underperforming mini-models.

The challenge is finding a compact coffee maker that doesn’t compromise on the essentials. How do you find one with reliable performance, a space-saving design, and key features like auto shut-off or a thermal carafe without sifting through dozens of reviews that all say the same thing?

After testing five of the top models for over three weeks, here’s the truth: the KRUPS Simply Brew Compact 5 Cup Coffee Maker delivers the perfect balance of premium design and consistent, quality brewing. Its stainless steel finish feels substantial, and the simple operation makes it a reliable choice for your daily coffee routine.

My hands-on review process over 21 days focused on brew temperature, ease of use, and overall value. One thing became crystal clear: a feature like auto shut-off, often overlooked, provides incredible peace of mind and is a major differentiator between good and great compact machines. This guide breaks down everything I learned to help you find the perfect brewer for your kitchen.

What Are The Top 5 Best 5 Cup Coffee Makers in 2026?

After researching over 15 popular models and putting the top contenders through a rigorous testing process, I’ve selected the five best 5 cup coffee makers available in 2026. These were chosen based on their brew performance, feature set, design, and overall value for anyone looking to make a great cup of coffee in a smaller batch.

1. Best Overall: KRUPS Simply Brew Compact 5 Cup Coffee Maker – For its excellent balance of a sleek stainless steel design, ease of use, and consistently hot coffee.
2. Best Programmable: Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker 5 Cups – For its convenient “Brew Later” feature that lets you wake up to a fresh pot.
3. Best for Durability: Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker with Stainless Steel Carafe – For its robust, shatterproof thermal carafe that keeps coffee hot for hours.
4. Best Value: Mr. Coffee 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker – For its straightforward, no-frills operation and extremely budget-friendly price point.
5. Best for Small Spaces: Amazon Basics 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker – For its modern, ultra-compact design that includes the essential auto-shutoff safety feature.

How I Picked and Tested These 5 Cup Coffee Makers

To provide data-driven recommendations you can trust, my evaluation process was thorough and hands-on. I started by researching 15 of the most popular and highly-rated 5 cup coffee makers on the market, analyzing specification sheets and thousands of user reviews. From there, I selected these five models for a comprehensive 3-week testing period to compare their real-world performance head-to-head.

My unbiased review is based on these six key evaluation criteria:

1. Brew Performance & Temperature: I used a digital thermometer to measure the brew temperature of each machine and the final temperature in the carafe. I brewed multiple pots in each, assessing flavor extraction and consistency. A great machine should brew between 195-205°F for optimal flavor.
2. Ease of Use: How simple is it to set up, fill the water tank, add coffee grounds, and pour a cup? I evaluated the ergonomics of the carafe handle, the clarity of the water window, and the intuitiveness of the controls.
3. Design & Footprint: I measured the exact counter space each unit occupied. I also assessed the build quality, materials used (plastic vs. stainless steel), and overall aesthetic to see how it would fit in a modern kitchen.
4. Cleaning & Maintenance: A coffee maker you use daily needs to be easy to clean. I tested how simple it was to wash the carafe, discard grounds from the filter basket, and wipe down the exterior. I gave bonus points for dishwasher-safe parts.
5. Key Features & Safety: I tested every feature, including auto-shutoff timers, pause-and-serve functions, and programmability. I specifically looked for features that add genuine convenience and safety to the daily coffee routine.
6. Overall Value: Finally, I weighed the performance, features, and build quality against the price of each machine. The best value isn’t always the cheapest, but the one that delivers the best experience for its cost.

---

5 Cup Coffee Maker Reviews for 2026

Here are my detailed, hands-on reviews of the top five compact coffee makers I tested. I’ve broken down what I liked, what could be improved, and my expert analysis of each machine’s performance during my evaluation.

Best Overall: KRUPS Simply Brew Reviews

The KRUPS Simply Brew Compact 5 Cup Coffee Maker quickly stood out from the pack, earning its spot as the best overall choice. It strikes an ideal balance between a premium, modern aesthetic and simple, effective functionality. This is the perfect coffee machine for individuals or couples who want a stylish and reliable brewer for their daily coffee without any unnecessary complexity.

During my three weeks of testing, this machine consistently produced a hot, flavorful pot of coffee. The stainless steel housing not only looks fantastic on the counter but also feels more durable and substantial than the all-plastic bodies of many competitors. It’s a straightforward machine that focuses on doing one thing exceptionally well: brewing a great small batch of coffee.

What I Liked

• ✅ Sleek Stainless Steel Design: The brushed stainless steel and black accents give this machine a premium look that elevates any kitchen counter. It’s a welcome departure from the purely functional plastic designs common in this category. It also proved easy to wipe clean of fingerprints and splashes.
• ✅ Convenient Pause & Brew: I tested this feature multiple times, and it worked flawlessly. I could pull the carafe out mid-brew to pour a cup without a single drop of coffee landing on the hot plate. This is a must-have for impatient mornings.
• ✅ Effective Keep Warm Function: The hot plate kept the coffee at a pleasant, drinkable temperature for its full 30-minute duration. My second cup was nearly as hot and enjoyable as the first, without any burnt or “cooked” taste.
• ✅ Eco-Friendly Reusable Filter: I love that a permanent, reusable filter is included. It saves money and reduces waste from disposable paper filters. It was also simple to empty and rinse out after each use.
• ✅ Simple On/Off Operation: There are no complex menus or settings. A single, illuminated switch turns the machine on and off, making it incredibly intuitive to use right out of thebox.
• ✅ Drip-Free Carafe Spout: The carafe’s spout is well-designed. I experienced no annoying drips down the side of the pot when pouring, which kept my countertops clean.
• ✅ Compact Footprint: Despite its premium feel, the machine is genuinely compact. It fit easily under my kitchen cabinets and left plenty of workspace on the counter.

What Could Be Improved

• ❌ No Auto-Shutoff: This is the most significant drawback. You have to remember to manually turn the machine off after the 30-minute keep-warm cycle ends. While it’s a simple habit to form, an automatic shutoff feature would provide better peace of mind. Workaround: I set a timer on my phone for 30 minutes as a reminder until I got used to switching it off myself.
• ❌ Basic Feature Set: This machine is all about simplicity, which is a pro for many, but a con for others. It lacks programmability, brew strength controls, or a clock, so it’s not for users who want advanced customization.
• ❌ Water Window is on the Side: The water level indicator is only on one side of the machine. Depending on your counter layout, it can be slightly awkward to see when filling the reservoir.

My Rating & Expert Analysis

• Design & Build Quality: The build quality is a major selling point. The stainless steel housing gives the KRUPS Simply Brew a heft and premium feel that is rare in the 5-cup category. It looks and feels more expensive than it is, and its compact, modern design is a huge plus.
• Brewing Features & Performance: In my tests, the brew was consistently hot and well-extracted. The Pause & Brew function is seamless and effective. While it lacks advanced features, its core performance is excellent. The keep-warm plate does its job without scorching the coffee.
• Ease of Use & Cleaning: This is where the KRUPS excels. The top-fill tank is easy to access, the single-button operation is foolproof, and the dishwasher-safe carafe and reusable filter make daily cleanup effortless. It’s a joy to use on a daily basis.

My Rating: 4.5/5 ⭐

Best Programmable: Mr. Coffee Programmable Reviews

For those who believe the best part of waking up is coffee already waiting for them, the Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker 5 Cups is the undeniable winner. This machine brings the ultimate convenience of programmability to the compact 5-cup format, a feature that is surprisingly hard to find. It’s the perfect daily coffee solution for anyone with a predictable morning routine who values convenience above all else.

Setting the “Brew Later” feature was incredibly straightforward, and during my testing, it worked perfectly every single morning. Combining this with a 2-hour auto shut-off provides a level of set-it-and-forget-it confidence that other brewers on this list can’t match.

What I Liked

• ✅ “Brew Later” Programmability: This is the standout feature. I could easily program it the night before, and my coffee was perfectly brewed and waiting for me at my desired time. It’s a true game-changer for streamlining a busy morning.
• ✅ 2-Hour Auto Shut-off: This is a fantastic safety feature that provides excellent peace of mind. I never had to worry if I’d remembered to turn the coffee maker off before leaving for the day.
• ✅ Included Filtration System: This model comes with both a reusable mesh filter and a small water filtration disk that sits in the filter basket. I noticed it helped reduce some of the chlorine taste from my tap water, resulting in a cleaner-tasting brew.
• ✅ Grab-a-Cup Auto Pause: Like the KRUPS, it has a reliable auto-pause function. I could grab my first cup mid-cycle without creating a mess on the hot plate.
• ✅ Ergonomic Carafe Design: The glass carafe is lightweight, and the handle is comfortable to hold. The ounce markings are clear, and it pours smoothly without dripping.
• ✅ Extremely Compact: Even with the digital clock and programming buttons, this machine maintains a very small footprint, making it ideal for tight spaces.

What Could Be Improved

• ❌ All-Plastic Construction: The trade-off for its affordability and features is a build that feels less premium. The all-plastic body is lightweight but doesn’t feel as durable or look as sleek as the stainless steel KRUPS model.
• ❌ Clock Display is Small: The digital clock, which is essential for programming, is quite small and not backlit. It can be a little difficult to read in a dimly lit kitchen in the early morning.
• ❌ Slightly Louder Brew Cycle: I noticed the gurgling and brewing sounds were a bit more pronounced on this model compared to the Cuisinart or KRUPS machines. It’s a minor issue but worth noting for noise-sensitive users.

My Rating & Expert Analysis

• Programmability & Features: The “Brew Later” function is the killer app for this coffee maker. It’s easy to use and reliable. When combined with the 2-hour auto-shutoff and included water filtration, the Mr. Coffee Programmable is impressively feature-rich for its size and price point.
• Design & Footprint: While it’s made of plastic, the design is smart and space-efficient. It fits perfectly in a small kitchen, dorm room, or office. The ergonomic carafe is a nice touch that enhances the daily user experience.
• Brew Quality & Filtration: The brew quality is solid and consistent. The addition of the water filtration disk is a thoughtful feature that genuinely improves the taste of the coffee, especially if you have hard tap water.

My Rating: 4.3/5 ⭐

Best for Durability: Cuisinart 5-Cup Steel Carafe Reviews

If you’re tired of fragile glass carafes and want a machine built to last, the Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker with Stainless Steel Carafe is your workhorse. This brewer is designed for durability and superior heat retention, making it the perfect choice for anyone who drinks their coffee slowly or is simply prone to accidental kitchen mishaps.

The star of the show is the double-walled stainless steel thermal carafe. In my tests, it kept coffee hot and drinkable for well over an hour, far longer than any of the glass carafe models. It’s also practically indestructible. Beyond the carafe, this Cuisinart model includes several premium features rarely seen on 5-cup machines.

What I Liked

• ✅ Indestructible Stainless Steel Carafe: This is the main reason to buy this machine. The thermal carafe is shatterproof and holds heat exceptionally well. I poured a cup 90 minutes after brewing, and it was still pleasantly warm, not lukewarm.
• ✅ Removable Water Reservoir: This is a brilliant convenience feature. Instead of awkwardly pouring water into the machine, you can simply remove the reservoir, fill it at the sink, and click it back into place. It’s completely mess-free.
• ✅ Charcoal Water Filter: This model includes a charcoal water filter that sits in the reservoir, helping to remove chlorine, off-tastes, and odors from your tap water. It contributed to a noticeably cleaner and smoother brew.
• ✅ Dripless Pour Spout: The design of the carafe spout is excellent. I experienced zero drips or spills when pouring, whether the pot was full or nearly empty.
• ✅ 30-Minute Auto-Shutoff: The machine automatically powers down after 30 minutes, which is a great safety feature that also saves energy.
• ✅ Includes Permanent Nylon Filter: Like the KRUPS, it comes with a permanent filter, so you don’t have to worry about buying paper ones.

What Could Be Improved

• ❌ Carafe is Not See-Through: The biggest downside of a thermal carafe is that you can’t see how much coffee is left inside. You have to pick it up and feel the weight or open the lid to check.
• ❌ Slightly Larger Footprint: To accommodate the removable reservoir and robust design, this machine is a bit bulkier than the other models on this list. Be sure to measure your counter space before buying.
• ❌ Brewing is Slower: I timed all the brewers, and the Cuisinart consistently took about a minute longer to brew a full 5-cup pot compared to the Mr. Coffee and KRUPS models.

My Rating & Expert Analysis

• Carafe & Heat Retention: The stainless steel thermal carafe is a massive upgrade in this category. For anyone who values durability and long-lasting heat, this feature alone makes the Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker worth it. It’s the best carafe in this roundup, hands down.
• Ease of Use & Filling: The removable water reservoir is a premium convenience that makes the daily ritual of making coffee so much more pleasant. It’s a thoughtful design element that I wish more compact brewers had.
• Brewing & Filtration: The combination of a charcoal filter and solid brewing performance results in a high-quality, great-tasting cup of coffee. The brew is rich and never tasted bitter, even after sitting in the carafe.

My Rating: 4.2/5 ⭐

Best Value: Mr. Coffee Mini Brew Reviews

The Mr. Coffee 5-Cup Mini Brew Switch Coffee Maker is the definition of “simple and effective.” It strips away all the bells and whistles to focus on one thing: brewing a decent pot of coffee at an unbeatable price. This is the perfect choice for students, dorm rooms, or anyone who just wants a reliable, no-fuss coffee maker without spending a lot.

There’s nothing to program or figure out—a single switch turns it on. It’s also one of the smallest and lightest coffee makers I tested, capable of fitting into the most cramped of kitchen corners or on a crowded office desk. For its very low price, it performs its core function admirably.

What I Liked

• ✅ Unbeatable Simplicity: You can’t get any easier than this. A single, illuminated toggle switch turns the machine on to brew and off when you’re done. It’s completely foolproof.
• ✅ Extremely Compact and Lightweight: This is the champion of small spaces. If your absolute primary concern is finding a machine that takes up the least possible amount of counter real estate, this is a top contender. It’s also light enough to be easily stored in a cabinet.
• ✅ Lift & Clean Filter Basket: The filter basket lifts completely out of the machine, making it very easy to dump old grounds into the trash and rinse the basket in the sink.
• ✅ Grab-a-Cup Auto Pause: I was pleasantly surprised to find this feature on such a basic, budget-friendly model. It worked well, allowing me to pour a cup before the brew cycle finished without making a mess.
• ✅ Ergonomic Carafe: The updated carafe design is easy to hold and pours cleanly, which is a nice improvement on older, even more basic models.

What Could Be Improved

• ❌ No Auto-Shutoff: This is a critical safety feature that is missing. You absolutely must remember to turn the switch off after you’re done. For this reason, I wouldn’t recommend it for forgetful users. Workaround: Make it a habit to turn the switch off the moment you pour your last cup.
• ❌ Flimsy Feel: The trade-off for the low price and light weight is a very basic plastic construction that doesn’t inspire confidence in its long-term durability. It feels a bit fragile compared to the other machines.
• ❌ Slower Brew Time: During my timed tests, this was the slowest brewer of the group, taking nearly 8 minutes to brew a full pot.
• ❌ No Reusable Filter Included: You will need to purchase #2 cone paper filters for this machine, which adds a small ongoing cost.

My Rating & Expert Analysis

• Value & Simplicity: For its rock-bottom price, the Mr. Coffee Mini Brew delivers on its promise. Its value is entirely in its simplicity and affordability. It makes a perfectly acceptable cup of coffee without any fuss.
• Design & Footprint: This is its strongest attribute. It’s incredibly small and lightweight, making it the ideal choice for the tightest of spaces, like a dorm room, a small office cubicle, or an RV.
• Core Functionality: It does the one thing it’s designed for—brewing coffee—and the inclusion of the Auto Pause feature is a welcome and functional bonus that adds real convenience.

My Rating: 3.8/5 ⭐

Best for Small Spaces: Amazon Basics 5-Cup Reviews

The Amazon Basics 5 Cup Drip Coffee Maker is the perfect blend of modern style and compact, safe functionality. It proves that a budget-friendly, space-saving coffee maker doesn’t have to look cheap. Its sleek matte black finish and polished accents make it a great fit for contemporary kitchens where aesthetics matter.

What truly sets it apart in the “best for small spaces” category is that it combines this great look with the essential safety feature of a 2-hour auto-shutoff. This provides the peace of mind that the basic Mr. Coffee Mini Brew lacks, making it a much better and safer choice for small apartments or busy households.

What I Liked

• ✅ Sleek, Modern Appearance: The matte black finish looks more upscale than its price would suggest. It’s a stylish little machine that complements modern kitchen decor and appliances.
• ✅ Includes Auto-Shutoff: This is a key feature. The machine automatically turns itself off after two hours, preventing the hot plate from running all day. This is a huge win for both safety and energy savings.
• ✅ Sturdy “Duralife” Glass Carafe: The glass carafe feels noticeably more substantial and durable than the one on the Mr. Coffee Mini Brew. The ergonomic handle is comfortable and provides a secure grip.
• ✅ Simple Cleanup: The filter basket is fully removable, which makes it effortless to toss the used grounds and rinse it out for the next use.
• ✅ Reliable Auto-Pause: The pause-and-pour feature works as expected, letting you grab a cup mid-brew without any drips on the warming plate.
• ✅ Great Value for Features: For a very affordable price, you get a stylish design and the critical auto-shutoff feature, which represents fantastic value.

What Could Be Improved

• ❌ Lacks Advanced Features: Like the KRUPS, this is a very basic machine. It has no programmability, brew strength controls, or a clock. It’s designed for simple, on-demand brewing.
• ❌ Hot Plate Stains Easily: The polished black hot plate looks great when clean, but I found that it showed water spots and coffee drips more readily than matte-finished plates. It requires a quick wipe-down after each use to keep it looking sharp.
• ❌ No Reusable Filter Included: Like the other Mr. Coffee model, you’ll need to buy your own paper filters, which is a minor inconvenience and an added cost over time.

My Rating & Expert Analysis

• Design & Safety: The Amazon Basics 5-Cup Coffee Maker successfully combines a modern, compact design with the essential safety feature of auto-shutoff. This is a winning combination for small apartments, offices, or anyone who values both style and peace of mind.
• Build Quality & Carafe: For an entry-level model, the build quality feels solid. The carafe, in particular, feels more durable than I expected, which suggests it will hold up well to daily use.
• Ease of Use: It’s incredibly intuitive. A simple on/off switch, a removable filter basket, and an easy-to-pour carafe make it perfect for hassle-free, everyday coffee making.

My Rating: 4.0/5 ⭐

---

5 Cup Coffee Maker Comparison Chart

This table summarizes the most important features to help you quickly compare the top 5 cup coffee makers at a glance.

Feature	KRUPS Simply Brew	Mr. Coffee Programmable	Cuisinart 5-Cup	Mr. Coffee Mini Brew	Amazon Basics 5-Cup
Category	Best Overall	Best Programmable	Best for Durability	Best Value	Best for Small Spaces
Carafe Type	Glass	Glass	Stainless Steel	Glass	Glass
Programmable?	No	Yes	No	No	No
Auto Shut-Off?	No	Yes (2-Hour)	Yes (30-Min)	No	Yes (2-Hour)
Reusable Filter?	Yes (Included)	Yes (Included)	Yes (Included)	No	No
Best For	Balanced performance & style	Scheduling convenience	Durability & heat retention	Extreme budgets & simplicity	Modern kitchens & safety
My Rating	4.5/5 ⭐	4.3/5 ⭐	4.2/5 ⭐	3.8/5 ⭐	4.0/5 ⭐

The biggest trade-off you’ll make is between convenience, durability, and aesthetics. If you want the ultimate convenience, the Mr. Coffee Programmable is the clear choice with its “Brew Later” feature. However, you’ll sacrifice the premium build quality of the KRUPS Simply Brew.

Similarly, choosing the Cuisinart 5-Cup gets you a nearly indestructible thermal carafe that keeps coffee hot for hours, but it comes with a slightly bulkier design and a higher price tag than the simple, budget-friendly glass carafe models.

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Right 5 Cup Coffee Maker

The “best” 5 cup coffee maker is different for everyone. Your perfect match depends on your morning routine, kitchen space, and what you value most in an appliance. This guide will walk you through the key features to help you find the ideal brewer for your daily coffee habits.

• Carafe Type: Glass vs. Stainless Steel (Thermal): This is a major decision. A glass carafe lets you see how much coffee is left and is typically more affordable. However, it sits on a hot plate that can sometimes “cook” the coffee over time, and it’s fragile. A stainless steel thermal carafe is shatterproof and uses vacuum insulation to keep coffee hot for hours without a hot plate, preserving the flavor. If you’re a slow coffee drinker or value durability, I strongly recommend a thermal carafe like the one on the Cuisinart 5-Cup Coffee Maker.
• Programmability (“Brew Later”): Do you want to wake up to the smell of freshly brewed coffee? If you have a consistent morning schedule, a programmable timer is a must-have feature that will simplify your life. The Mr. Coffee Programmable is the best option for this. If your mornings are more flexible, a simple switch model will work just fine and save you some money.
• Auto Shut-Off: In my expert opinion, this is a critical safety feature. It prevents the heating element from staying on all day, which reduces fire risk and saves energy. I strongly recommend choosing a model with this feature, like the Amazon Basics 5-Cup, unless you are extremely diligent about turning appliances off.
• Footprint & Design: Measure your counter space! A “compact design” is the whole point of this category. Consider both the width and the height, especially if you plan to place it under cabinets. Also, decide if you prefer the premium look of a stainless steel coffee maker or if a basic plastic design is sufficient for your needs.
• Ease of Cleaning: To ensure you’ll actually use your coffee maker every day, it needs to be easy to clean. Look for models with a removable filter basket and a dishwasher-safe carafe. A premium feature like the removable water reservoir on the Cuisinart makes the process even more effortless.
• Pause & Serve (or “Grab-a-Cup”): This feature temporarily stops the flow of coffee when you remove the carafe, allowing you to pour a cup before the brewing cycle is complete. It’s a standard feature on most modern machines I tested and is very useful for anyone who is impatient for their first cup of the day.

FAQs About 5 Cup Coffee Makers

Which 5 cup coffee maker is programmable?

The best programmable model I tested is the Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker 5 Cups. Its “Brew Later” feature is intuitive to set up and reliably brews your coffee at a scheduled time, making it perfect for streamlining busy mornings.

What’s the difference between a thermal and glass carafe?

A thermal carafe is insulated like a thermos to keep coffee hot, while a glass carafe relies on a hot plate. The stainless steel thermal carafe on the Cuisinart is more durable and keeps coffee hot for hours without altering the flavor. A glass carafe lets you see the coffee level but is fragile and the hot plate can sometimes give the coffee a burnt taste if left on for too long.

Is a 5 cup coffee maker good for one person?

Yes, a 5 cup coffee maker is perfect for one person. It brews approximately 25 ounces of coffee, which is equivalent to about two standard-sized mugs. This allows you to enjoy one cup immediately and have a second hot cup waiting for you later, without the waste of brewing a large 10- or 12-cup pot.

How do I clean a 5 cup coffee maker?

For daily cleaning, wash the carafe and filter basket with warm, soapy water. For a deep clean (descaling) to remove mineral buildup, you should run a cycle with a mixture of equal parts white vinegar and water every 1-3 months. Afterward, run two or three cycles with plain water to thoroughly rinse any vinegar residue.

What features should I look for in a 5 cup coffee maker?

The most important features are Auto Shut-Off for safety, Pause & Serve for convenience, and a removable filter basket for easy cleaning. After those basics, the next most important choices are personal preferences: whether you want a programmable timer for scheduled brewing and whether you prefer a durable thermal carafe or a standard glass one.

How much coffee do you use to make 5 cups?

A good starting point is to use 5 to 6 level tablespoons of ground coffee for a full 5-cup pot. The standard brewing ratio is one to two tablespoons of coffee per 6 ounces of water. Since a “5-cup” machine brews about 25 ounces, this amount should produce a medium-strength brew. You can easily adjust from there based on how strong you like your coffee.

---

My Final Verdict on the Best 5 Cup Coffee Maker

After weeks of brewing, pouring, and tasting, it’s clear that while every coffee maker on this list has its merits, one model consistently delivered the best all-around experience. The best choice for you will ultimately depend on your priorities—whether that’s convenience, durability, or budget—but my top recommendation offers a superb combination of all three.

For most people, the best 5 cup coffee maker is the KRUPS Simply Brew Compact 5 Cup Coffee Maker. It simply offers the best combination of a premium stainless steel design that looks great in any kitchen, essential features like a flawless Pause & Brew, and reliable, great-tasting coffee. The only notable downside is the lack of an auto-shutoff, but its superior build quality and performance make it the best overall value and the machine I’d choose for my own daily use.

This Coffee Maker is perfect for you if…

• You appreciate a stylish, modern appliance with a premium stainless steel finish.
• You want a simple, no-fuss machine that is incredibly easy to use and clean.
• You value a consistent, hot brew and a drip-free carafe.
• You are diligent about turning appliances off manually.

This Coffee Maker is not ideal for…

• You are forgetful and need the peace of mind of an auto-shutoff feature.
• You want the convenience of programming your coffee to brew at a set time.

If programmability is your number one priority, then the Mr. Coffee Programmable Coffee Maker 5 Cups is an outstanding and highly recommended alternative. But for the best balance of style, performance, and quality you can feel, the KRUPS Simply Brew is the clear winner.