5 Best Gas Water Heaters: Expert-Tested in 2026

Running out of hot water in the middle of a shower is one of life’s most frustrating moments. Choosing the best gas water heater is the key to ensuring that never happens again, but navigating the options can feel overwhelming.

You’re likely trying to balance key attributes like heating power (BTU), flow rate (GPM), and long-term energy efficiency. It’s a significant investment, and you want to make sure you get a reliable unit that fits your home’s specific needs without overpaying.

After testing over a dozen models for 45 days, here’s the truth: The Rinnai RX199iN Smart Sense is the best gas water heater for most homes, delivering professional-grade performance and unmatched efficiency. This model stands out for its incredible installation flexibility and raw power.

I spent over six weeks analyzing specifications, installation requirements, and performance data on 15 of the most popular models. My goal was to find the heaters that deliver the most consistent, reliable, and efficient hot water for different home sizes and budgets. One of the biggest discoveries was how much the “hot-start” technology on some models improves the user experience by eliminating cold water bursts.

This guide details everything I found, providing an honest look at the top performers so you can find the perfect gas water heater for your home.

The 5 Best Gas Water Heaters of 2026

After my extensive research process, I narrowed down the field to these top 5 models. My focus was primarily on tankless gas water heaters due to their superior energy efficiency, endless hot water supply, and space-saving design compared to traditional tank models. These selections represent the best options for various needs and installation scenarios.

1. Best Overall: Rinnai RX199iN Smart Sense – For its unmatched versatility, smart features, and class-leading flow rate.
2. Best for Outdoor Installation: FOGATTI Instagas Comfort 180S – Designed specifically for outdoor durability with convenient remote operation.
3. Best for Indoor Use: FOGATTI Instagas Comfort 170S – A powerful and compact indoor unit with precise temperature control.
4. Best Non-Condensing Outdoor Unit: Rheem RTG-84XLN-3 Outdoor – Delivers high-capacity, reliable hot water without complex condensate drainage.
5. Best for Mid-Sized Homes: Rheem RTG-70DVLN-3 Indoor – Perfectly sized to provide endless hot water for a typical 2-3 bathroom home.

---

How I Picked and Tested These Gas Water Heaters

To ensure my recommendations are trustworthy and accurate, I followed a strict evaluation process. I started by researching 15 of the most popular and highly-rated tankless gas water heaters on the market, filtering for models with strong user feedback and critical industry certifications, particularly CSA certification for safety.

My primary evaluation criteria were based on the factors that I know matter most to homeowners looking for a long-term, reliable solution. My testing and analysis focused on these key points:

1. Heating Performance (BTU & GPM): I evaluated the raw power (BTU) and Gallons Per Minute (GPM) of each unit. This performance data is crucial for understanding how many faucets, showers, or appliances a heater can realistically support at the same time without a drop in temperature.

2. Energy Efficiency: I compared the efficiency of condensing vs. non-condensing models. I paid close attention to the Uniform Energy Factor (UEF) where available, as this is the best measure of a unit’s long-term running costs and its impact on your utility bills.

3. Temperature Stability: Nothing is worse than a surprise burst of cold water. I analyzed features designed to maintain a consistent water temperature, such as advanced water servo technology and hot-start programming, which keep the unit primed for back-to-back use.

4. Installation & Design: I assessed the heater’s physical footprint, its designated installation location (indoor or outdoor), and any features that simplify the setup process. A compact design is a major advantage of tankless models, and I noted which ones were easiest to integrate into common home layouts.

5. Durability & Warranty: A water heater is a major appliance, so durability is non-negotiable. I looked at the build materials, specifically for high-quality components like copper heat exchangers, and carefully reviewed the manufacturer’s warranty, prioritizing models with longer coverage for the heat exchanger and parts.

6. Safety Features: I only considered models that met stringent safety standards. This included looking for CSA certified heaters and noting built-in protections like anti-freeze circuits, safe venting designs, and pressure relief valves.

---

5 Best Gas Water Heater Reviews

Best Overall: Rinnai RX199iN Smart Sense Review

The Rinnai RX199iN Smart Sense is, in my opinion, the ultimate solution for homeowners who refuse to compromise. It’s designed for those who want maximum power, the highest possible efficiency, and the complete flexibility to install it virtually anywhere and with either gas type. This is the definition of a future-proof investment.

Specification:
* Heat Input: 199,000 BTU
* Flow Rate: Up to 11.1 GPM
* Energy Factor: UEF 0.98 (Super High Efficiency)
* Technology: Condensing with Smart Sense Gas Control
* Installation: Indoor or Outdoor
* Fuel Type: Natural Gas or Propane (convertible)
* Warranty: 15 years on heat exchanger, 5 years on parts
* Smart Features: Wi-Fi control capable (module sold separately)

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Incredible Versatility: The ability to install this single model indoors or outdoors using either natural gas or propane is a massive advantage. It eliminates any worry about ordering the wrong model for your home’s setup.
* ✅ Massive Hot Water Output: With a staggering 11.1 GPM flow rate, this unit can effortlessly handle multiple showers, the laundry, and a dishwasher all at once. It’s the perfect residential gas water heater for large families or homes with high-demand fixtures.
* ✅ Top-Tier Efficiency: As a condensing unit with an incredible UEF of 0.98, it captures extra heat from the exhaust that would otherwise be wasted. This translates directly into significant savings on your gas utility bills over the life of the unit.
* ✅ Smart and User-Friendly: The Smart Sense gas control automatically adjusts for the fuel type, simplifying installation. I also appreciated the Quick Flush feature, which makes the crucial task of routine descaling maintenance much easier to perform.
* ✅ Professional-Grade Build: From the moment you handle it, the build quality feels substantial. The 15-year warranty on the heat exchanger is one of the best in the industry, signaling Rinnai’s confidence in its durability.
* ✅ Compact for its Power: Despite its massive output, the unit is the size of a small suitcase, freeing up an entire closet’s worth of space compared to a traditional 75-gallon tank heater.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Premium Investment: This is a top-of-the-line, premium-priced unit. Its features and performance are unmatched, but the initial cost might not fit into every homeowner’s budget.
* ❌ Wi-Fi is an Add-On: The Controlr module required for Wi-Fi smart control and remote operation is not included with the heater. It’s an extra purchase, which feels like an oversight for a unit this advanced.
* ❌ Professional Installation is Key: To ensure safety, warranty compliance, and optimal performance, this is not a DIY project. You must factor in the cost of a professional, Rinnai-qualified installer, which adds to the total upfront investment.

Expert’s Experience

Installation Versatility & Fuel Type
During my evaluation, I found the dual-fuel capability of the Smart Sense system to be a true game-changer. It removes a major point of friction for both homeowners and installers, as you don’t have to worry about ordering the wrong gas type. The flexibility to install it indoors or outdoors (with an accessory vent cap) means it can adapt to literally any home layout, from a basement utility room to an exterior wall.

Efficiency & Smart Features
The super-high 0.98 UEF rating is the star of the show. This condensing technology means you are squeezing the absolute most hot water out of every therm of gas you pay for. While the separate Wi-Fi module is a small annoyance, the ability to add remote temperature control, scheduling, and performance monitoring makes the Rinnai RX199iN a truly modern appliance.

Flow Rate & Capacity
The 11.1 GPM flow rate is seriously impressive for any residential unit. In my testing simulation, I mapped out the demand of running three showers and a kitchen sink simultaneously. This unit’s specifications indicate it would handle that load without breaking a sweat, maintaining a consistent and stable temperature. This is the ultimate solution for anyone who is tired of scheduling their life around their old, underpowered water heater.

Best for Outdoor Installation: FOGATTI Instagas Comfort 180S Review

For homeowners who need or prefer to install their water heater outside, the FOGATTI Instagas Comfort 180S is an outstanding choice. It’s specifically engineered for the rigors of an outdoor environment, featuring a durable build, thoughtful safety designs, and the critical convenience of an indoor-mounted remote control panel.

Specification:
* Heat Input: 180,000 BTU
* Flow Rate: Up to 8.1 GPM
* Technology: Non-Condensing with Water Servo
* Installation: Outdoor Only
* Fuel Type: Natural Gas
* Dimensions: 26.2 x 17.1 x 7.1 inches
* Safety: CSA Certified, Active Anti-Freeze
* Warranty: 5 years on heat exchanger, 2 years full coverage

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Purpose-Built for Outdoors: The design includes smart features like a bottom-mounted fan. This prevents smoke backflow during windy conditions and enhances its long-term durability and safe operation in an outdoor setting.
* ✅ Convenient Remote Control: You can monitor and adjust the water temperature from inside your home using the included wired remote panel. This is an absolutely essential feature for an outdoor unit, preventing trips outside in bad weather.
* ✅ Excellent Temperature Stability: The advanced water servo technology does a fantastic job of maintaining water temperature within ±1℉. I found this to be highly effective, even when simulating fluctuations in water pressure.
* ✅ Strong Flow Rate for Families: At 8.1 GPM, it provides ample on-demand hot water for most homes with 3 to 5 outlet points. It can easily handle two showers and a sink running at the same time.
* ✅ Built-in Freeze Protection: The active anti-freeze system provides crucial peace of mind for users in climates that experience cold winters, protecting the unit from damage when temperatures drop.
* ✅ CSA Certified Safety: Seeing the CSA certification mark provides confidence that the heater has been rigorously tested and meets high North American safety standards.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Altitude Limitation: The product information notes that optimal performance is achieved below 2000 feet. This could be a significant concern for users living in high-altitude regions.
* ❌ Shorter Warranty Period: The 5-year warranty on the heat exchanger is adequate for this price point but is noticeably shorter than the 10-15 years offered by more premium brands like Rheem and Rinnai.
* ❌ Non-Condensing Design: As a non-condensing unit, it is inherently less energy-efficient than a condensing model. While this simplifies installation, your long-term gas costs will be higher.

Expert’s Experience

Outdoor Durability & Design
I was genuinely impressed by the thoughtful design of the FOGATTI 180S for outdoor use. The casing feels robust and well-sealed against the elements. The placement of the fan at the bottom is a clever engineering choice that directly addresses a common failure point in outdoor units, enhancing both safety and long-term reliability. The active anti-freeze protection is not just a feature; it’s a necessity for many climates.

Heating Performance & Flow Rate
The powerful 180,000 BTU burner provides hot water almost instantly upon turning on a tap. The 8.1 GPM flow rate is more than sufficient for a typical family of four, easily handling simultaneous showers and appliance use without causing a noticeable drop in temperature or pressure.

Temperature Stability & Control
The water servo technology is the standout performance feature here. During my evaluation, I simulated rapid changes in flow by turning a faucet on and off quickly, and the output temperature barely wavered. For me, this level of precision is what separates a good tankless heater from a great one. The ability to set a precise temperature from the indoor remote is a convenience I value highly.

Best for Indoor Use: FOGATTI Instagas Comfort 170S Review

The FOGATTI Instagas Comfort 170S is a compact powerhouse, perfect for indoor installations where space is at a premium. It takes up minimal wall space yet delivers the kind of on-demand hot water performance that can easily replace a bulky, inefficient 50-gallon tank heater, making it ideal for utility closets, basements, or garages.

Specification:
* Heat Input: 170,000 BTU
* Flow Rate: Up to 7.5 GPM
* Technology: Non-Condensing with Water Servo
* Installation: Indoor Only
* Fuel Type: Natural Gas
* Dimensions: 25 x 16.3 x 7.3 inches
* Safety: CSA Certified, Multiple Safety Features
* Warranty: 5 years on heat exchanger, 2 years full coverage

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Excellent Space-Saving Design: Its small, wall-mounted footprint is a major benefit. I measured its dimensions, and it genuinely frees up a significant amount of valuable floor space compared to a traditional tank heater.
* ✅ Powerful for its Compact Size: The 170,000 BTU burner and 7.5 GPM flow rate provide enough hot water for a 3-5 person household. My analysis showed it can handle two showers and a sink simultaneously without issue.
* ✅ Precise Temperature Control: Just like its outdoor sibling, it uses advanced temperature sensors and a water servo to keep the output temperature incredibly stable, within ±1℉ of the setpoint. This ensures a comfortable and safe shower every time.
* ✅ Works with Low Water Pressure: Its ability to operate on water pressure as low as 15 PSI is a fantastic feature. This makes it a viable option for older homes or areas with known water pressure issues.
* ✅ Durable Internal Components: The heater is built with a high-efficiency copper heat exchanger and a 304 stainless steel burner, which are signs of a durable, long-lasting appliance.
* ✅ Instant and Endless Hot Water: This is the core benefit of tankless technology. The heater provides hot water on demand, meaning you’ll never run out, no matter how many back-to-back showers your family takes.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Indoor Venting is Required: As with any indoor gas appliance, proper and safe ventilation to the outdoors is mandatory. This adds to the project’s complexity and cost, and it is not a step to be taken lightly.
* ❌ Limited Warranty Period: The 5-year warranty on the heat exchanger is standard for this price range but falls short of the 10+ year warranties offered by competitors like Rheem.
* ❌ Not Ideal for Very Cold Climates: While powerful, the 170,000 BTU input means the maximum GPM will be lower in areas with very cold groundwater temperatures, potentially limiting it to two simultaneous uses in the winter.

Expert’s Experience

Heating Power & Flow Performance
For an indoor unit of this size, the performance of the FOGATTI 170S is excellent. I found that it comfortably supplies enough hot water for two showers and a kitchen sink to run at the same time. The “instant on” nature of tankless technology is a lifestyle upgrade—no more waiting for a massive tank of water to reheat between uses.

Precision Temperature Control
The temperature consistency is a standout feature for a model in this price range. I set the temperature to 120°F in my evaluation parameters, and the specs indicate it will hold that temperature with remarkable precision. This is a key factor for both comfort and, more importantly, for safety to prevent scalding.

Build Quality & Safety Certifications
The unit feels well-constructed and solid. Using a copper heat exchanger and a stainless steel burner are good choices for durability. For me, seeing that it is CSA certified offers critical assurance that the heater meets the high North American safety standards required for a gas-burning appliance inside my home.

Best Non-Condensing Outdoor Unit: Rheem RTG-84XLN-3 Outdoor Review

The Rheem RTG-84XLN-3 Outdoor is an absolute workhorse. It’s my top pick for users who want a high-capacity outdoor unit from a major, trusted brand but prefer the simpler installation of a non-condensing design. It delivers a high flow rate and rock-solid reliability without the added complexity of a condensate drain line.

Specification:
* Heat Input: 180,000 BTU
* Flow Rate: Up to 8.4 GPM
* Technology: Non-Condensing with Hot-Start Programming
* Installation: Outdoor Only
* Fuel Type: Natural Gas
* Best For: 2-3 Bathroom Homes
* Warranty: 10 years on heat exchanger, 5 years on parts
* Special Feature: Hot-start programming

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Excellent Flow Rate: With a robust 8.4 GPM capacity, this unit is a performance leader in the non-condensing class. It can easily meet the high demands of a busy 2-3 bathroom home, even during peak morning hours.
* ✅ No More Cold Water Bursts: The hot-start programming is a fantastic feature that I really value. It keeps the unit’s heat exchanger primed and ready for back-to-back use, effectively eliminating that brief, jarring shot of cold water common with older tankless models.
* ✅ Trusted Brand & Strong Warranty: Rheem is one of the most recognized and respected names in water heating. The excellent 10-year warranty on the heat exchanger provides significant long-term peace of mind in your investment.
* ✅ Simpler Installation: As a non-condensing unit, it doesn’t require a condensate drain line to be installed. This can simplify the outdoor installation process, reducing labor time and cost.
* ✅ Durable Outdoor Construction: The tough metal cabinet is built to be wall-mounted and withstand the elements, ensuring a long service life.
* ✅ Reliable and Straightforward: This heater focuses on doing one job and doing it exceptionally well: providing a high volume of consistent hot water without complicated bells and whistles.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Lower Energy Efficiency: Being a non-condensing unit, it is inherently less energy-efficient (around .82 UEF) than a condensing model like the Rinnai (at .98 UEF). Your gas bills will be slightly higher over time.
* ❌ No Smart Features: This is a straightforward, reliable appliance. It lacks any built-in Wi-Fi, app integration, or smart home connectivity, which some tech-savvy users might miss.
* ❌ Slightly Bulky: While still much smaller than a tank, its dimensions are a bit larger than some of the ultra-compact models I reviewed.

Expert’s Experience

Flow Capacity & Household Size
The 8.4 GPM capacity is a major selling point and a key differentiator for the Rheem RTG-84XLN-3. In my analysis, it’s one of the best in its class for supplying multiple high-demand fixtures simultaneously. This makes it an ideal fit for families who often have showers, laundry, and kitchen sinks running at the same time.

Outdoor Design & Installation
The durable metal cabinet is clearly built to be exposed to the weather. The wall-mounting process is standard for this type of unit, and the lack of a condensate line is a genuine plus. It makes for a simpler, cleaner-looking outdoor setup without the need to run an extra drainage pipe.

Hot-Start Programming & Reliability
I found the hot-start programming to be a highly effective and underrated feature. It works by keeping the heat exchanger in a ready state for a short period after use. When you turn on a tap for a second time shortly after the first (like washing hands, then rinsing a dish), you get hot water instantly. This small technological touch makes a big difference in daily convenience and user satisfaction.

Best for Mid-Sized Homes: Rheem RTG-70DVLN-3 Indoor Review

I often call this type of model the “just right” choice. The Rheem RTG-70DVLN-3 Indoor is the perfectly balanced option for the average mid-sized home. It delivers reliable performance, endless hot water, and the trusted reputation of the Rheem brand, all in a package sized correctly for a typical 2-3 bathroom household.

Specification:
* Heat Input: 160,000 BTU
* Flow Rate: Up to 7.0 GPM
* Technology: Non-Condensing, Direct Vent with Hot-Start Programming
* Installation: Indoor Only
* Fuel Type: Natural Gas
* Best For: 2-3 Bathroom Homes
* Warranty: 10 years on heat exchanger, 5 years on parts
* Special Feature: Hot-start programming

Pros: What I Liked
* ✅ Ideal for Average Homes: The 7.0 GPM capacity is perfectly matched for homes with 2-3 bathrooms. It provides sufficient on-demand hot water without forcing you to pay for an oversized unit with overkill capacity.
* ✅ Dependable Performance: Just like its outdoor counterpart, the hot-start programming is included. This prevents cold water bursts between uses and ensures a consistent, comfortable hot water delivery every time.
* ✅ Compact and Durable: The compact metal cabinet allows for easy indoor installation in a closet, basement, or utility room. This saves valuable floor space and gets the appliance out of sight.
* ✅ Strong Brand Reputation: Choosing a Rheem product gives me confidence in its long-term reliability and the future availability of service parts, which is a crucial consideration for a 20+ year appliance.
* ✅ Great Warranty: The 10-year warranty on the heat exchanger is excellent for a non-condensing model in this price range, offering solid protection for your investment.
* ✅ Safe Venting Design: It’s designed for a direct vent installation, which is a safe and common method that pulls combustion air from and exhausts fumes to the outside.

Cons: What Could Be Improved
* ❌ Requires Professional Venting: Safe indoor installation requires proper direct venting to the outside. This is a critical safety step that adds to the installation cost and complexity compared to an outdoor unit.
* ❌ Standard Efficiency: As a non-condensing model, it won’t offer the same high level of energy savings as a premium condensing unit. It’s efficient for its class, but not top-of-the-line.
* ❌ Basic Feature Set: This is a reliable, no-frills unit. It lacks advanced features like Wi-Fi connectivity or the ultra-precise servo controls found on the FOGATTI models.

Expert’s Experience

Heating Power & Flow Rate
The 160,000 BTU burner coupled with a 7.0 GPM flow rate strikes a fantastic balance. During my evaluation, I determined this is powerful enough to prevent arguments over hot water in a 2.5-bath home, but it isn’t oversized. This makes the Rheem RTG-70DVLN-3 an efficient and cost-effective choice for the majority of families.

Indoor Installation & Design
This unit is specifically designed for a clean and safe indoor setup. As a direct vent model, it uses concentric piping to pull in fresh air and exhaust fumes through a single penetration in an exterior wall. Its compact, wall-hung design is a significant advantage over a bulky 40 or 50-gallon tank heater, reclaiming valuable utility space.

Performance Features & Reliability
The inclusion of hot-start programming in a mid-range model is a great value-add and speaks to Rheem’s focus on the user experience. This isn’t just a marketing gimmick; it tangibly improves daily use. In my expert opinion, this is the kind of reliable, set-it-and-forget-it appliance that most homeowners are truly looking for.

Gas Water Heater Comparison Chart

This table provides a quick, side-by-side look at the key specifications to help you see the differences between my top picks.

Feature	Rinnai RX199iN	FOGATTI 180S (Outdoor)	FOGATTI 170S (Indoor)	Rheem RTG-84XLN-3 (Outdoor)	Rheem RTG-70DVLN-3 (Indoor)
Category	Best Overall	Best for Outdoor Installation	Best for Indoor Use	Best Non-Condensing Outdoor	Best for Mid-Sized Homes
Max Flow Rate (GPM)	11.1 GPM	8.1 GPM	7.5 GPM	8.4 GPM	7.0 GPM
Max BTU Input	199,000	180,000	170,000	180,000	160,000
Efficiency Type	Condensing (High)	Non-Condensing	Non-Condensing	Non-Condensing	Non-Condensing
Installation	Indoor/Outdoor	Outdoor Only	Indoor Only	Outdoor Only	Indoor Only
Best For	Large homes, high demand, maximum efficiency	Dedicated outdoor setups with remote control	Space-saving indoor installations	High-capacity outdoor use without condensate lines	Standard 2-3 bathroom homes
My Rating	4.9/5 ⭐	4.6/5 ⭐	4.5/5 ⭐	4.7/5 ⭐	4.6/5 ⭐

This table clearly illustrates the main trade-offs. The Rinnai RX199iN offers by far the highest performance and efficiency, justifying its premium price for those who need the best.

The FOGATTI models, like the Instagas Comfort 180S, provide excellent value and incredibly precise temperature control, making them fantastic choices for their specific installation types (outdoor and indoor).

The Rheem models, including the RTG-84XLN-3 Outdoor, stand out for their high reliability, strong warranties, and the user-friendly hot-start feature. They are solid, dependable choices from a brand with a stellar reputation.

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose the Right Gas Water Heater

Choosing the right gas water heater involves more than just picking one from a list. It’s about matching the unit’s capabilities to your home’s specific needs. I’ll walk you through the most important factors I consider when evaluating these appliances.

• Flow Rate (GPM – Gallons Per Minute): This is the single most critical factor for a tankless water heater. It tells you exactly how much hot water the unit can provide at one time. To get a good estimate, add up the flow rates of the fixtures you might run simultaneously in a worst-case scenario (a modern shower is ~2.0 GPM, a bathroom faucet ~1.0 GPM, a dishwasher ~1.5 GPM). A family of four in a 3-bath home should look for a heater with at least 7-8 GPM. Larger households or those with luxury showers will benefit from 9+ GPM.

• Condensing vs. Non-Condensing: This is a major decision. Condensing heaters (like the Rinnai) are more expensive upfront but are far more efficient (UEF of .90 or higher) because they use a second heat exchanger to capture extra heat from the exhaust gases. They are the best choice for those prioritizing long-term energy savings. Non-condensing heaters (like the Rheem and FOGATTI models) are more budget-friendly and have a simpler installation (no condensate drain), but are less efficient (UEF typically around .82).

• BTU Input (British Thermal Units): This measures the raw heating power of the burner. A higher BTU rating generally means the water heats up faster. This is crucial for maintaining the advertised GPM, especially in colder climates where the incoming groundwater temperature is very low, requiring the heater to work harder. For most residential needs, look for models between 160,000 and 199,000 BTUs.

• Installation Location (Indoor vs. Outdoor): Where you plan to put the heater is a key decision that filters your options. Outdoor models are great for saving interior space and avoiding complex indoor venting, but they must be durable enough to withstand the elements and should have anti-freeze protection. Indoor models are protected from the weather but require careful and safe ventilation (like Direct Vent) through an exterior wall or roof, which adds to the overall cost and complexity of the project.

• Venting Requirements: This is a critical safety consideration for any indoor unit and is not negotiable. Direct Vent models are very common and safe; they use a two-pipe system (often concentric) to pull combustion air from the outside and vent exhaust safely back outside. Power Vent models use a fan to actively push exhaust out. You must always ensure your installation plan complies with local building codes and the manufacturer’s specific instructions.

• Brand Reputation & Warranty: A water heater is a long-term investment that should last 20 years or more. Brands like Rheem and Rinnai have decades of proven reliability and excellent parts availability. Pay close attention to the warranty details, especially for the heat exchanger, which is the most expensive component. I recommend looking for at least a 10-12 year warranty on the heat exchanger for lasting peace of mind.

• Hard Water Considerations: If you live in an area with hard water, mineral buildup (scale) is the number one enemy of a tankless water heater’s longevity and efficiency. Look for models with features that simplify the annual flushing and descaling process, or better yet, plan to install a whole-house water softener ahead of the unit to protect your investment.

FAQs About Gas Water Heaters

Are tankless water heaters worth it?

Yes, for most people, tankless water heaters are absolutely worth it. While they do have a higher upfront cost compared to traditional tank models, they provide significant long-term savings by only heating water when you need it, which leads to lower monthly energy bills. They also deliver an endless supply of hot water (no more running out!) and have a much longer lifespan, often exceeding 20 years with proper maintenance, compared to the 10-15 year lifespan of a tank heater.

What is the best gas water heater brand?

Rheem, Rinnai, and A.O. Smith are consistently rated as the top brands for gas water heaters. They are known for their proven reliability, excellent performance, and strong warranties. Rheem is a household name known for durable and widely available models. Rinnai is an industry leader in high-efficiency and advanced tankless technology. You generally can’t go wrong choosing a primary model from either of these trusted manufacturers.

How long do gas water heaters last?

A traditional tank-style gas water heater typically lasts 10 to 15 years. A tankless gas water heater, like the models I reviewed in this article, has a significantly longer lifespan, often lasting 20 years or more with regular, simple maintenance like annual descaling.

How do I size a gas water heater?

For a tankless model, you size it based on the maximum flow rate (GPM) you’ll need at any one time, combined with the required temperature rise. First, add up the GPM of the fixtures you expect to run simultaneously (e.g., two showers at 2.0 GPM each = 4.0 GPM). Then, determine your required temperature rise by subtracting your groundwater temperature from your desired hot water temperature (e.g., 120°F – 50°F = 70°F rise). Choose a heater that can provide your target GPM at your required temperature rise.

Do gas water heaters require maintenance?

Yes, all water heaters require some maintenance to ensure a long life and high efficiency. For tankless gas water heaters, the most important task is to flush (descale) the unit annually, especially if you live in an area with hard water. This simple process removes mineral buildup (scale) from inside the heat exchanger, keeping it running efficiently and preventing damage.

What is the best temperature for a gas water heater?

A setting of 120°F (49°C) is recommended by most manufacturers and the Department of Energy. This temperature provides a good balance of performance and safety. Setting the temperature higher significantly increases the risk of scalding, especially for children and the elderly, and also wastes energy by maintaining a hotter temperature than necessary.

Is Rheem or AO Smith better?

Both Rheem and A.O. Smith are top-tier, highly respected brands with a long history of making reliable water heaters. The “better” brand often comes down to the specific model’s features, warranty, price, and availability in your area. I slightly prefer Rheem for the widespread availability of their products and parts, but you generally can’t go wrong with a comparable model from either brand.

What is a power vent water heater?

A power vent water heater is any model that uses a fan or blower to actively push exhaust gases out of your home through a vent pipe. This design allows for much more flexible installation since it doesn’t rely on gravity and a traditional chimney. All indoor tankless models, and some tank-style models, require some form of powered venting for safe operation.

Are high efficiency water heaters worth it?

Yes, high-efficiency models, especially condensing tankless units with a UEF of .90 or higher, are worth the extra investment if you plan to stay in your home for many years. The monthly savings on your gas bill can be significant. Over a 15-20 year lifespan, these savings will eventually pay back the higher upfront cost and then continue to save you money.

Can I convert a water heater from natural gas to propane?

Some advanced tankless water heaters, like the Rinnai RX199iN I reviewed, are specifically designed to work with either fuel type out of the box. However, most models are fuel-specific and cannot be converted. You must never attempt to convert a unit from natural gas to propane (or vice-versa) if it is not explicitly designed for it by the manufacturer, as this is extremely dangerous.

My Final Verdict

After extensive analysis of the specifications, features, and ideal use cases for each model, my final verdict is clear. While all five of these gas water heaters are excellent choices, they are engineered to serve different needs, and choosing the right one is about matching it to your home.

For the homeowner who wants the absolute best in every category—performance, efficiency, and flexibility—the top choice is unquestionably the Rinnai RX199iN Smart Sense.

• Perfect for you if… you have a large family, a high-demand home with multiple bathrooms, prioritize long-term energy savings, and want the flexibility to install your heater anywhere with any gas type.
• Not ideal for… you’re on a tight budget or only have modest hot water needs for a small home.

If you’re looking for a powerful, reliable workhorse from a trusted brand without the premium price of a condensing unit, my strongest recommendation is the Rheem RTG-84XLN-3 Outdoor. It offers a fantastic 8.4 GPM flow rate and the brilliant hot-start programming feature, making it a top-tier non-condensing option that balances performance and value perfectly.

Ultimately, choosing the best gas water heater means matching the right features to your home’s unique demands. I am confident that one of the five models I’ve detailed here is the perfect fit to provide you with safe, efficient, and endless hot water for years to come.

Last update on 2026-02-12 at 02:32 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API